In the twenty-second episode of the fifth season ofÂ Deep Space Nine, what the fuck is wrong with this show? Intrigued? Then itâ€™s time for Mark to watchÂ Star Trek.Â
This show just canâ€™t leave me alone. LOOK, I AM JUST ONE INNOCENT FAN, WHY MUST YOU DO THIS TO ME.
Star TrekÂ has used the vehicle of science fiction to give us a number of ethical problems over the years, and â€œChildren of Timeâ€ certainly feels like a veryÂ Star TrekÂ conflict. (Iâ€™m thinking of â€œTuvixâ€ and my heart hurts.) YetÂ Deep Space NineÂ finds a way to tie this ethical conundrum into an existing storyline just so they can hurt us even more. But letâ€™s say the Odo/Kira part doesnâ€™t exist. Even without it, this is one hell of a nightmare. After crashing on a planet with a weird energy boundary, the crew on theÂ DefiantÂ meets their descendants. How is that possible? Well, when they tried to leave, they hit a temporal anomaly, got sent two hundred years in the past, and got stranded, thus creating the very colony theyâ€™re interacting with in the present time.
Iâ€™m sure you can see the problem, but I didnâ€™t, at least not until Sisko vocalized it: if theÂ DefiantÂ crew successfully left the planet, then they never crash land in the past and their descendants never exist. OH GOD, THIS IS A NIGHTMARE. And the writers donâ€™t make this any easier forÂ anyoneÂ involved. Kira is dead in this timeline; everyone has adorable and living descendants. (Why donâ€™t we see any of Julianâ€™s? I thought that was strange.) The Dax symbiont is in a new Trill host, Klingon culture is still thriving, the Oâ€™Brien family line is alive and well. Everything here challenges these people to reconsider leaving.
And thatâ€™s the huge problem, isnâ€™t it? Does it count as murder or, at the very least, unethical for these people to use their scientific prowess in order to escape this timeline? Up until the point where Jadzia discovers that Yedrin lied about the sensor logs, there wasnâ€™t much of an issue, since I believed theyâ€™d be able to split theÂ DefiantÂ into two timelines. However, Yedrinâ€™s desire to preserve himself andÂ two hundred years of historyÂ seems less heinous when you consider that he â€“ and literally every single member of the 8,000+ population of that settlement â€“ will pop out of existence the second theÂ DefiantÂ leaves. And what does that mean to each of these characters?
Iâ€™ll touch on Kira last, but for some, leaving is no question. Oâ€™Brien and Sisko want to return home because theyâ€™ve got family back at the station. Julian has no reason to stay. Worf and Jadzia are fascinated by their descendants, but thereâ€™s no real connection there beyond admiration. What works so well about â€œChildren of Timeâ€ is how theÂ DS9Â crew slowly comes to believe that leaving is morally wrong. Kiraâ€™s the first to insist that this is a terrible idea, but soon, each of them come to believe theyâ€™re doing something awful by leaving.
Oh god, we have to talk about Kira, though.
A Glimpse of the FutureÂ andÂ the Present
But the absolute best part of this episode is our glimpse of Future Odo, one who has learned to shapeshift into human form better than ever before, one who has opened up as a person, who is more willing to share his life and feelings with others. WHICH HE DOES BY IMMEDIATELY TELLING KIRA THAT HE LOVES HER AND HAS LOVED HER FOR A VERY LONG TIME. The brilliance of this partially comes from the fact that I did not expect this to come out into the open in this episode, despite that we learned that Kira and Shakaar were no longer seeing each other. The shock of it is a great story choice, but getting to see this version of Odo â€“ a glimpse of a possible storyline with him â€“ pushes Kira into wanting to stay. In a way, thatâ€™s heartbreaking. She believes that life only allows for one path, and she chooses the one where she dies, all so that 8,000 other people can live.
But she also chooses the oneÂ withoutÂ any chance at a relationship with Odo, and I canâ€™t help but feel crushed by this. Itâ€™s understandable, of course, and the final part of â€œChildren of Timeâ€ makes it clear that a relationship isnâ€™t even a possibility with Kira at this time. However,Â Deep Space NineÂ avoids a common trope byÂ notÂ having Kira immediately swoon over Odo. Sheâ€™s surprised by the revelation, she takes Odo seriously, but she also doesnâ€™t believe that what Future Odo did for her â€“ altering theÂ Defiantâ€™sÂ flight plan so that they all survive their exit â€“ was all that romantic or fair.
Instead, â€œChildren of Timeâ€ feels remarkably honest for such an absurd premise. Itâ€™s because the writers ground everything in believable characters and believable responses to the situation.
Iâ€™M STILL A MESS, THOUGH.
The video for â€œChildren of Timeâ€ can be downloadedÂ here for $0.99.
Mark Links Stuff
– I am now on Patreon! There are various levels of support, from $1 up to whatever you want! You’ll get to read a private blog, extra reviews, and other such rewards. I POST A LOT OF CUTE PHOTOS, OKAY. Think of it like a private Tumblr blog that only SPECIAL PEOPLE get to read.
– I have updated my list of conventions and events for the remainder of the year and much of next year.Â Â Check the full list of events on my Tour Dates / Appearances page.
– My Master Schedule is updated for the near and distant future for most projects, so please check it often.Â My next Double Features for Mark Watches have been announced here.
-Â Mark Does Stuff is on Facebook!Â I’ve got a community page up that I’m running. Guaranteed shenanigans!